Islander Inn Put-in-Bay, Put-in-Bay | Explore Room Options, Reviews & Pricing for 2025

Book on our site and save

up to 10%

over Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

225 Erie St, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States of America, OH 43456

The 2-star Islander Inn features Put-in-Bay's largest outdoor complex with 3 pools, 2 bars, and a 30-person hot tub surrounding 100 recently renovated rooms. The property houses a full-service shop and sits in downtown Put-in-Bay's entertainment district.

Modern Room Amenities

Islander Inn accommodates guests in rooms with air conditioning, flat-screen TVs with cable channels, and private bathrooms with walk-in showers. Select units offer pool-view balconies, while others feature courtyard views.

Pool Bars

The Nauti Perch Day Club serves beverages at its swim-up bar with 9 underwater seats and additional land seating. A second bar features 5 swing seats and specializes in frozen drinks.

Pools and Entertainment

Three pools include a heated pool, lazy river with lounge chair island, and swim-up bar pool. Weekend entertainment features DJs, contests, and poolside games like cornhole.

Key Attractions Nearby

The Islander Inn stands 0.5 miles from Perry's Victory Memorial and 0.8 miles from Perry's Cave. Detroit Metro Airport is 47 miles away, while Toledo Express Airport is 74.5 miles from the property.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Queen Room

Max:

2 persons

325 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Quadruple Room

Max:

2 persons

325 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Pool view

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

King Room

Max:

2 persons

325 sq. feet

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Pool view

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Available transportation options

City Center

Put-in-Bay700 ft

Airports

Toledo Express (TOL) 72.5 mi

Cleveland Hopkins International (CLE) 77.1 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Free Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi in public areas

Parking

USD 15 per day

Baggage storage

24-hour services

24-hour security

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Paid parking
No pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
24-hour security
Baggage storage
Elevator
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Vending machines
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers
Key card access

Services

Paid shuttle service
Housekeeping
Welcome drink
Happy hour

Dining

Poolside snack bar
Picnic area/ Tables

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities

Facilities for people with disabilities

Toilet for disabled

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Heated swimming pool
Sun loungers
Jacuzzi
Shallow end

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Sitting area
Garden furniture

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

225 Erie St, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States of America, OH 43456

Map view

225 Erie St, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States of America, OH 43456

City landmarks

Monuments and Landmarks

Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial

2300 ft

Put in Bay

Perry's Cave

4200 ft

820 Catawba Ave

Chocolate Museum

4200 ft

979 Catawba Ave

Perry's Cave Family Fun Center

4200 ft

Botanical Garden

Butterfly House

4200 ft

Bayview Avenue

Oak Point State Park

5200 ft

Southern tip of South Bass Island

South Bass Island Lighthouse

1.6 mi

East Pont

Scheeff East Point Preserve

1.5 mi

2 Bayside Ave

DeRivera Park

1.5 mi

Island

Middle Bass Island

2.1 mi

Starve Island

1.7 mi

1719 Fox Road

Middle Bass Island State Park

1.6 mi

Winery

Lonz Winery

2.1 mi

Bass Islands

2.3 mi

Nearby

808 Langram Rd

Stonehenge Estate

1600 ft

Put in Bay

Aquatic Resource Center

1600 ft

Put in Bay

Alaskan Birdhouse Wildlife Museum

1600 ft

Island

South Bass Island

1600 ft

Restaurants

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

600 ft

439 Loraine Ave

The Chicken Patio

1100 ft

234 Delaware St

Subway

1600 ft

272 Delaware St # Commodore Hotel

Dairy Isle

2200 ft

213 Bayview Ave

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

62%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily return

6.2/10

Nice

Rooms

6.0

Location

9.0

Service

6.2

Dining

6.8

Doug

United States of America, March 2025

7.2/10

My stay at Islander Inn had its ups and downs. The location was fantastic, being right in the heart of Put-in-Bay, which made exploring super convenient. However, the room had a musty smell and was quite dated, and I found the noise from the pool area a bit overwhelming. While the staff was friendly and accommodating, the overall experience didn't quite meet my expectations. 🌊🏨

Rooms

5.0

The room was old and musty with worn sheets, but it was clean.

Service

5.0

Staff were friendly, but my initial check-in experience was rude.

Location

9.0

Excellent location, easy access to main attractions.

Dining

8.0

Dining options nearby were convenient and diverse.

Facilities

6.0

Basic facilities like a mini fridge were lacking, and the pool area was quite loud.

Bruce

United States of America, February 2025

5.4/10

During my stay at Islander Inn, I experienced a mix of ups and downs. The location was fantastic, super close to everything I wanted to explore. However, I was disappointed with the room conditions—some outdated elements and cleanliness issues made it feel less than ideal. Overall, I had some fun moments, but there are definitely areas for improvement.

Rooms

6.0

My room felt outdated and had cleanliness issues, which really affected my comfort. I also missed having a coffee machine or microwave, something I'm used to when I travel.

Service

8.0

The staff was friendly and helpful, especially the front desk. They were quick to assist me when I had questions or needed a golf cart, which was a big plus for me.

Location

9.0

The hotel's location is spot-on. I loved being able to walk to the main strip and access everything easily—definitely a highlight of my trip.

Dining

Facilities

5.0

I wish I could've used the pool as they closed it early on my first night, which was super disappointing. I expected better access given the nice area outside.

Edward

United States of America, November 2024

7.4/10

My stay at Islander Inn was a mixed experience. While the location was perfect for exploring Put-in-Bay, the facilities left much to be desired. The hotel felt outdated, and the cleanliness of the pools was disappointing, impacting my overall enjoyment.

Rooms

5.0

The room was clean but outdated, and I found it uncomfortable due to the worn-out mattress. There were also tiny ants around, which is not acceptable for a room charging over $200 a night.

Service

5.0

The front desk staff were friendly and helpful, especially during checkout. However, it was frustrating that the pool closed unexpectedly right after I checked in, and they offered no compensation for the misunderstanding.

Location

8.0

The hotel's prime location makes it easy to get to downtown and other attractions, which I really appreciated. Being in the center of everything was a major plus for my trip.

Dining

6.0

While I didn’t dine extensively at the hotel, the nearby dining options were appealing, especially for those who enjoy local cured meats.

Facilities

5.0

The hot tub was disappointing as it felt unclean and barely warm, which I found quite off-putting. Additionally, the pool's water was freezing, which was not what I had hoped for.

Brian

United States of America, November 2024

6.4/10

I enjoyed my stay at Islander Inn, mainly due to its excellent location near everything in Put-in-Bay. The pools and on-site bars added a nice touch, but the overall maintenance could use some improvement, especially the pool area. My experience was generally positive, though a few minor issues detracted from it.

Rooms

8.0

The rooms were clean and comfortable, updated with fresh paint and furniture. However, they weren't fancy and some bathrooms showed signs of wear.

Service

8.0

The staff at the front desk were friendly and approachable, helping me with any questions I had. They even assisted me in securing a golf cart for exploring the island.

Location

10.0

The location was a huge plus. I could walk easily to shops, restaurants, and attractions, making it very convenient for exploring Put-in-Bay.

Dining

6.0

While the hotel offered limited dining options on-site, there were plenty of restaurants nearby, so I found it easy to grab meals. It would have been nice to have more variety available without leaving the premises.

Facilities

6.0

The hotel had multiple pools and a hot tub which could be great in warmer weather. However, I noticed some maintenance issues in these areas that could be improved.

David

United States of America, October 2024

5.4/10

My stay at the Islander Inn had some pros and cons. I appreciated the hotel's great location, making it easy to walk to shops and restaurants. However, I encountered issues with cleanliness and maintenance, which detracted from my overall experience. The air conditioning wasn't as cool as I hoped, and I found some areas that needed attention, such as the bathroom facilities. 🏝️😕

Rooms

6.0

While my room was clean and provided a comfortable bed, the air conditioning could have been colder. I encountered some maintenance issues as well, which detracted from my experience.

Service

5.0

The staff were generally pleasant and accommodating, but I felt the response to cleanliness issues could have been better.

Location

9.0

The location was fantastic, allowing easy access to all the main attractions on the island.

Dining

7.0

I didn't dine extensively at the hotel, but I enjoyed the convenient location for grabbing meals nearby.

Facilities

5.0

The facilities include beautiful pools and hot tubs, though I noticed some areas that needed cleaning and maintenance, which was disappointing.

Ready to discover our exclusive early booking deals?

Enjoy exclusive rates!

Check Rates